Naughty Mistletroll - Legendary from Golden Mistletoe

Nautilus

Nessie - Legendary from Scottish Pets Update 2023

Ninja Monkey - Legendary from Monkey Fairground

Octopus - Legendary from Ocean Egg

Orange Butterfly

Orchid Butterfly - Legendary from Butterfly Sanctuary 2025

Owl - Legendary from Farm Egg

Owlbear - Legendary

Papa Moose - Legendary from Maple Leaf Treat

Parrot - Legendary from Jungle Egg

Pelican - Ultra-Rare from September 2023 (Robux)

Peppermint Penguin - Ultra-Rare from Winter 2023 (Robux)

Phoenix - Legendary from Mythic Egg

Pig - Rare from Farm Egg

Pink Cat - Uncommon from Pink Egg

Pink Egg - Rare from Special

Pirate Ghost Capuchin Monkey - Legendary from Capuchin Boxes

Pirate Hermit Crab - Legendary from Hermit Crab Box

Platypus - Ultra-Rare from Jungle Egg

Polar Bear - Rare from Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg)

Priceless Shrimp - Legendary from Summer Festival 2025

Princess Capuchin Monkey - Legendary from Capuchin Boxes