Shark Puppy - Legendary from Summer Festival 2023

Sheeeeep - Ultra-Rare from Meme Pets Update 2023 (Robux)

Shetland Pony Light Brown

Shrew - Rare from Christmas 2019 (Gingerbread)

Silly Duck - Uncommon from Farm Egg

Skele-Rex - Legendary from Halloween 2020 (Candy)

Slime - Ultra-Rare from Halloween 2023

Snow Monkey

Snow Owl - Legendary from Christmas 2020 (Gingerbread)

Snowball Pet

Spinosaurus - Legendary

Squid - Legendary

Strawberry Shortcake Bat Dragon - Legendary from Winter 2022 (Robux)

Sugar Axolotl - Legendary from Dia De Los Muertos 2024 (Robux)

Sugar Glider - Legendary from Easter 2022 (Robux)

Sunglider

Sunrise Duckling

Super Saru

Swan - Rare from Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg)

T-Rex - Legendary from Fossil Egg

Temple Friend

Tio De Nadal - Legendary from April Fools Day 2023 (Robux)

Tortuga de la Isla - Ultra-Rare from Summer Festival 2023 (Robux)